Part of the ‘On Second Thought’ series

By: Alex Sturman

When most people think of the Mishnah, they imagine dense ancient law.
When I think of the Mishnah, I see a management handbook.

Yes, you read that right. Two thousand years ago, the rabbis of the Mishnah were solving the same problems leaders wrestle with today: deadlines, clarity, conflicting instructions, procedures, inclusion, and communication.

Let’s look at just the first chapter of Tractate Berakhot, and see what it can teach modern leaders.

(Note: I’m using Vilna numbering. In Herbert Danby’s edition, which I’m working from, this section runs 1:1–1:5.)

---

1) Deadlines and Safeguards (Berakhot 1:1–1:3)

The Torah allows reciting the Shema until dawn, but the rabbis ruled:
“Say it by midnight.”
Why? To stop people from pushing things off until it’s too late.

💡 Leadership lesson: Don’t set your deadlines at the cliff edge. Build in buffers. Internal deadlines protect your team from last-minute disasters.

---

2) Starting When Clarity Appears (Berakhot 1:2)

The Mishnah says morning Shema starts when you can distinguish between blue and white — not when the sun is fully shining.

💡 Leadership lesson: Don’t wait for perfect certainty before starting. Begin once you see enough to act. Perfectionism kills opportunity.

---

3) Conflicting Instructions (Berakhot 1:4)

Beit Shammai said: lie down at night and stand in the morning.
Beit Hillel said: recite Shema however you are.
R. Tarfon once followed Shammai literally and put himself in danger — and was rebuked.

💡 Leadership lesson: When instructions conflict, choose the path that avoids unnecessary risk. Rigid literalism is not always wisdom.

---

4) Procedures vs. Improvisation (Berakhot 1:5)

The blessings around the Shema are fixed: some long, some short, some sealed, some not. Deviate from the formula, and the blessing is invalid.

💡 Leadership lesson: Procedures exist for a reason. Improvisation may feel creative, but when compliance, safety, or integrity are on the line, follow the structure.

---

5) Repetition Builds Clarity & Memory

(Danby 1:5 → Vilna 1:6–1:9)

The Mishnah insists the Shema be recited every day, twice, in the proper order.
Repetition and structure aren’t busywork; they’re design.
Rhythm creates recall, and recall enables action.

💡 Leadership lesson: Build supported repetition into your team’s rhythm — mentoring, coaching, drills, refreshers. Repetition + support turns know-what into know-how.

✅ Workplace examples:

• Onboarding cadence: shadow → simulate → supervised delivery → solo.
• Safety/compliance: short monthly drills in the same sequence.
• Sales/service: practice scripts with peers before going live.

---

✨ Takeaway for leaders today:
The Mishnah isn’t just history. It’s a living playbook for how to lead wisely, set structure, adapt with pragmatism, and respect both people and process.

👉 In Part II, I’ll explore how Berakhot talks about flexibility, inclusion, safety, and communication order (spoiler: they were wrestling with psychological safety long before we coined the phrase).

💡 Want more?
This was Part I of Leadership Lessons from the Mishnah.

📩 Want it delivered straight to your inbox?
Hit the subscribe link below.

---

Shalom Aleichem

---